I'm a sucker for nostalgia. That's why The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is one of my favorite movies. It's not a cinematic masterpiece or anything, so I'm a little embarrassed to admit that it ranks high up on my list, but I do think it was extremely underrated. There have been few movies that resonate with me like this one (or require quite as much Kleenex).
For starters, it's a period piece, which many times translates to nostalgia. But it's also philosophical, dealing with the fleeting passage of time, love in all forms, broken dreams, perspective, letting go, memories, forgiveness, and the inevitable. And these themes are like kryptonite to the extremely sentimental. But I think that anyone can see themselves in this film in some form or another. It's one of those movies, like Forrest Gump or O Brother Where Art Thou?, that I just have to watch if it's on TV.
But the most thought-provoking theme in Benjamin Button is a topic I've been reflecting on quite a bit lately: coincidence. One of my favorite scenes about coincidence involves Benjamin (the truly ageless Brad Pitt) narrating over a montage of clips showing unrelated people who, through a string of seemingly insignificant events, create a chain reaction of events that impacts Benjamin's ballerina love interest, Daisy, in a big way:
"Sometimes we're on a collision course, and we just don't know it. Whether it's by accident or by design, there's not a thing we can do about it.
A woman in Paris was on her way to go shopping, but she had forgotten her coat - went back to get it. When she had gotten her coat, the phone had rung, so she'd stopped to answer it; talked for a couple of minutes. While the woman was on the phone, Daisy was rehearsing for a performance at the Paris Opera House. And while she was rehearsing, the woman, off the phone now, had gone outside to get a taxi. Now a taxi driver had dropped off a fare earlier and had stopped to get a cup of coffee. And all the while, Daisy was rehearsing. And this cab driver, who dropped off the earlier fare, who'd stopped to get the cup of coffee, had picked up the lady who was going to shopping, and had missed getting an earlier cab. The taxi had to stop for a man crossing the street, who had left for work five minutes later than he normally did, because he forgot to set off his alarm.
While that man, late for work, was crossing the street, Daisy had finished rehearsing, and was taking a shower. And while Daisy was showering, the taxi was waiting outside a boutique for the woman to pick up a package, which hadn't been wrapped yet, because the girl who was supposed to wrap it had broken up with her boyfriend the night before, and forgot. When the package was wrapped, the woman, who was back in the cab, was blocked by a delivery truck, all the while Daisy was getting dressed. The delivery truck pulled away and the taxi was able to move, while Daisy, the last to be dressed, waited for one of her friends, who had broken a shoelace. While the taxi was stopped, waiting for a traffic light, Daisy and her friend came out the back of the theater.
And if only one thing had happened differently: if that shoelace hadn't broken; or that delivery truck had moved moments earlier; or that package had been wrapped and ready, because the girl hadn't broken up with her boyfriend; or that man had set his alarm and got up five minutes earlier; or that taxi driver hadn't stopped for a cup of coffee; or that woman had remembered her coat, and got into an earlier cab, Daisy and her friend would've crossed the street, and the taxi would've driven by. But life being what it is - a series of intersecting lives and incidents, out of anyone's control - that taxi did not go by, and that driver was momentarily distracted, and that taxi hit Daisy, and her leg was crushed."
I love that definition of life. But it's impossible to say what things in life happen for good reason (what I would call serendipity), what things happen for no apparent reason (what I would call mere coincidence), and what things are "God things" (like answered prayer or a customized trial containing a lesson we need to learn). And so goes an internal debate I've been pondering for awhile now.
An example of this concept happened just yesterday. It was Mom's 60th birthday, so we met for a Tex-Mex lunch and margaritas. As we got in our cars to leave, I waited for her to back out of her parking space first, which was a few over from mine. I glanced over my shoulder to see if all was clear, when I saw her minivan stopped in the middle of the road... without Mom in the driver's seat. "Oh no," I thought. An unhappy birthday surprise had indeed transpired, as a black little Altima coupe had parked just out of view and Mom backed right into it. We tried to find its owner in the restaurant, but to no avail. Mom left her number under the windshield wiper with an apology, and we left.
Happenstance #1: The car belonged to a young 20-something girl, who had just been involved in a hit-and-run. And because her car had taken the "hit," she was extremely grateful and appreciative that Mom had been honest and left her information. So instead of being upset with Mom, the girl was shockingly pleasant.
Happenstance #2: Mom had hoped she'd ran into someone who would be nice to her on her 60th birthday. Not only was the girl surprisingly agreeable, but they bonded over the fact that today is actually her birthday: only one day after Mom's.
Happenstance #3: The biggest (and baddest) coincidence of them all is this: the girl's 49-year-old father had died that same morning, just a few hours before Mom ran into her newly fixed car. She and her mom had stopped to eat before heading to the funeral home to make arrangements. Of course, Mom felt absolutely terrible. But she also had an immediate, and very dramatic, paradigm shift about her dreaded 60th birthday. Talk about perspective!
This series of events made me recall Benjamin's definition of life, that if XY and Z hadn't have happened, our lives wouldn't have intersected with this girl who was already having what was sure to be the worst day of her life thus far. The poor thing was on a collision course that day; she just didn't know it when she woke up.
"Along the way you bump into people who make a dent on your life." Benjamin's simple yet profound words make me wonder whether that literal dent Mom put on that girl's life can be chalked up to mere coincidence. It certainly wouldn't be considered serendipitous. But if those involved analyzed the situation from a deeper perspective, it could even be a God thing, spurring a paradigm shift and a potential chain reaction nobody could've foreseen.
All that to say this: Do the people who "make a dent in our lives" or the things that happen to us every day occur through coincidence, serendipity, or because of a higher power? Could one ever tell the difference?
"You never know what's coming for you."
-Benjamin Button